Letter: Wind easements come with ramifications

Posted 11/13/19

Editor:

Wind energy companies are a profit-first businesses with no regard for farmers or agriculture as evidenced by their disregard for the greatest soils in the world with their choice of …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

E-mail
Password
Log in

Letter: Wind easements come with ramifications

Posted

Editor:

Wind energy companies are a profit-first businesses with no regard for farmers or agriculture as evidenced by their disregard for the greatest soils in the world with their choice of placement.

For the sake of your children and grandchildren, do not sign a one-sided easement contract with its long-term ramifications.

Common factors in easement agreements are:

• They disallow you to construct a building or plant a tree that may interfere with air flow and restrict hunting. 

• They run with the property affecting its value if you sell or how your heirs want to use the land.

• They can be sold and resold.

• The developer can grant a co-easement or sub-easement, separate the easement, licenses, or other similar rights without your approval.

• The developer decides if you get a turbine, transmission lines, or other infrastructure. 

• You are not guaranteed a turbine and its related payments, you are granting the potential of a turbine.

• The developer decides where the location or number of turbines and access roads, not the landowner. 

• You give up your right to trial by jury.

• You agree to indemnity, meaning that you defend, indemnify (protect them from loss) and hold harmless the wind developer.

• You agree to confidentiality, you and your relatives are not to inform anybody about the financial terms, the product design, operations, construction, power production or your experiences with the company.

• Your contract may include a memorandum with a waiver to any setback agreements.

Other ramifications of an easement contract:

• A mechanic’s lien may be placed on your land if the developer fails to pay a contractor. 

• You may be named in a tort lawsuit for claims of injury or harm by those who live near wind turbines placed on your property. Tort law is regarding negligence, nuisance and trespass. The aspects of tort lawsuits involve the following: personal injury (adverse health effects), property damage (ice throw, water flow and tile damage, fire) or devaluation in property value, noise (including infrasound), communication signal interference, destruction of viewshed, flicker, shadow, electromagnetic field and stray voltage.

• In a case where the wind energy company holding the lease fails or if a tort lawsuit is won by the plaintiff, you, the landowner, may be held liable for damages.

• You may be held liable for a private nuisance claim from a neighbor due to interference with your neighbors right to use and enjoyment of their property.

• You may be held liable for a public nuisance claim for unreasonable activity that affects the entire community such as public health, safety and comfort.

• You may be held liable for a federal crime for the death of wildlife or interfering with their habitat. Eagles, migratory birds and endangered species are protected by the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act and the Endangered Species Act.

• It may affect any farm or conservation programs in which you participate.

• Industrial wind turbines will likely affect your federal estate tax valuation.

• The easement is and asset and used as collateral by the developer.  They may not permit you to exit the contract even if they are not exercising their use of your land.

Before you buy or rent farmland, do a title search to discover if there is a wind easement, covenants or agreements that will affect your use. Easement contracts have many pitfalls. Protect yourself and your heirs, do not sign one with a predatory wind energy company.

Kim Brenneman

Parnell